rattle bag vs antlers

vestafash70457 July 07, 2022 antlers , bag , rattle , vs Comment

Guess it really doesnt matter but i just dont feel like it. Hunters Specialties Ruttin Buck Rattling Bag The primary downside to a rattling bag is you cant generate the volume and deep sound to mimic two mature bucks fighting over a hot doe.

Rattling For Whitetails Pros And Cons Of Real Grand View Outdoors

Las Colinas Hunter 6873359 083017 0524 AM.

. Had first one their its new after but who not they have. Wich rattle bag sounds the best. Ive also found that rattling during the two-hour period either side of darkness works best.

It didnt come with any instructions on how to use it or tips. Personally I think antlers sound better. Jump to Latest Follow 21 - 23 of 23 Posts.

Rattle bags dont sound convincing to me when the are used gently and Ive never had any success with them. I rattled in a buck with the bag so im pretty sure they should work but wondering if anyone else uses them. Oct 31 2013 8 D deerhunter10 Well-Known Member Joined Aug 21 2012 Messages.

I have noticed that the bucks pay alot more attention to the antlers than the bag as well. They have many non seen before features and fit your hands just perfect. No matter how hard you try its simply not possible.

However merely placing a set of wooden rods in a cloth bag does not provide a realistic acoustic simulation of the sound. Packs Down Small - Unlike large antler deer rattling horn sets this lightweight and portable buck deer call packs into your bag to travel anywhere. Rattle Bag - This device is small and easy to use but it is harder to make louder rattling sequences with.

Both out of rattle bags. Its not like you are calling honkers from 3 miles away. Tired Wired and Uninspired Re.

Reply 09-07-2006 1121 AM 6 wis_bow_huntr. Also with real antlers I seem to have better control over how loud or soft I want to make it sound. Looking back I think I had more consistent results with antlers and am thinking about switching back.

Picked up a pair of those fake rattle antlers. I think it sounds more realistic being that the antlers are at ground level. Buy one today at ht.

I like light grunting and doe bleats. Oct 28 2008 2. Im sure that at enough times it dosent really make much of a diffrence beings the bucks systems running high during prerut and rut.

Nothing that I wanted to take. When rattling try to do it in the thickest cover possible especially if youre bow hunting. The sound of giant antlers clashing together may send smaller bucks running for cover but little fork horn antlers may draw little attention from the bull of the woods.

ELKMO41 Registered. Ive rattled in a few bucks but they were always curious young bucks. JamesBalog Registered Joined Jan 24 2009 841 Posts 2 Nov 7 2014.

The latter use of a rattle bag or rattle sack is growing in popularity. I also like to dangle my antlers from my rope I pull my bow up with on the ground while rattling. I used a set of antlers for several years with good results but switched to a rattling bag because of the convenience and ease of carrying.

Rattle bag vs antlers. I lightly grunt whether with buck or doe grunter. They are nearly as big as real antlers but.

5 Deer Rattling Tips How To Call In Big Bucks During The. Rattle bag or shed antlers. Ive had large bucks come running in to both.

Just be sure to take some time to learn how to work with the two separate full racks. Rattle Bag works well for me and it takes less movement on my part to make a louder rattling sound with the bag than it does using real horns or artificial antlers. To each his ownThe bag is easier to carry.

However dont rule out midday. The bag sounds a little muffled for me and real antlers sound more crisp and natural. Realized i lost my rattle bag so went to tsc and canadian tire.

Too often I see guys beating up those rattlebags like it was apart of their manhood. Black Rack - Black Rack is made by the Deer Society. Real antlers normally sound the best but there are a few options when it comes to rattling methods.

I like antlers because thats all Ive ever used. Are the rattle bags as good as real antlers. I also like the fact that they will hit brush and leaves doing this also.

Apparently they are supposed to sound more like the real mcoy. I get a better response when I rakerub the bagantlers on the bark of the tree and rattle them in the limbs then I do rattling them. Ive heard from reports around here that rattle bags are also good.

Rattle Bag These sound just as real to a buck are easy to pack because they are more compact and can be more discreet to use because you can rattle with one hand if necessary. Lets take a quick look at a couple and why you may want to use them. You can duplicate this light sound with a rattling bag and its so much easier to transport than real antlers.

Some people remove them so they dont smash your fingers i personally dont. Rather space the rattling sequences about 40-45 minutes apart. 2 of 2 Go to page.

At only 65 x 2 x 15 youll have plenty of space for all of your other deer hunting accessories and equipment. To Buy or to Learn more go to. They are moulded off a real buck they have been tested and work.

While rather clunky and less intuitive than a rattle bag or real set of antlers the Black Rack is versatile and can create just about any rattling sequence you need from sparring to a full-on territorial throwdown. On the downside they are less effective on windy days when you need more volume and they make it difficult to rake limbs and brush around you for that added realism. Plastic antlers are for foam deer targets.

Primos is the brand. Time and place are the keys to any rattling sequence but I like to use the real thing personally. I just bought the Knight Hale rattle bag from walmart it seems to be a higher pitch than i would expect.

Have rattled in some big boys with real antlers.

How To Rattle In Deer The Right Way An Official Journal Of The Nra